| NAME | | TERM | | NAME | | TERM |
| *John Gilbert, Jr. (1) | | 1857 | | *Charles L. Bennett (8) | | 1941 |
| *Nathaniel P. Jacobs (1) | | 1858-9 | | *Albert B. Lowrie (1) | | 1942 |
| *William P. Innes (5) | | 1860 | | *Edwin A. Mackey (25) | | 1943 |
| *Francis Darrow (2) | | 1861 | | *Frank G. Millard (15) | | 1944 |
| *John Clark (7) | | 1862 | | *J. Clifford Smith (17) | | 1945 |
| *Luman R. Atwater (5) | | 1863 | | *Elmer C. Geyer (16) | | 1946 |
| *Benjamin Porter, Jr. (19) | | 1864 | | *F. Campbell Bowers (33) | | 1947 |
| *Garra B. Noble (1) | | 1865 | | *Leonard J. Paterson (27) | | 1948 |
| *Seamon L. Dart (10) | | 1866 | | *Charles W. O'Donnell (32) | | 1949 |
| *Edward D. Benedict (5) | | 1867 | | *John N. Kirsch (18) | | 1950 |
| *John H. Armstrong (3) | | 1868 | | *Wilber M. Brucker (1) | | 1951 |
| *Theron A. Flower (2) | | 1869 | | *Fred England, Jr. (25) | | 1952 |
| *John L. Mitchell (9) | | 1870 | | *Howard D. Caulkin (5) | | 1953 |
| *Irving M. Smith (16) | | 1871 | | *George W. Campbell (21) | | 1953 |
| *Oliver L. Spaulding (24) | | 1872 | | *R. Dewey Stearns (16) | | 1954 |
| *Ellery I. Garfield (1) | | 1873 | | *Murray D. Wilson (42) | | 1955 |
| *Leonard H. Randall (5) | | 1874 | | *W. Edward Dewey (33) | | 1956 |
| *Salmon S. Matthews (2) | | 1875 | | *Roy E. Briggs (7) | | 1957 |
| *Samuel C. Randall (15) | | 1876 | | *Charles S. McIntyre (19) | | 1958 |
| *Hugh McCurdy (21) | | 1877 | | *Maurice B. Allen (25) | | 1959 |
| *Hollis F. Knapp (9) | | 1878 | | *Don C. Arner (29) | | 1960 |
| *Frank Henderson (8) | | 1879 | | *Edward S. Piggins (1) | | 1961 |
| *William B. Wilson (3) | | 1880 | | *Stanley G. Wilson (28) | | 1962 |
| *George W. Chandler (25) | | 1881 | | *John H. Loree (15) | | 1963 |
| *Charles E. Grisson (24) | | 1882 | | *Abner C. Sager (16) | | 1964 |
| *Jesse E. Saxton (1) | | 1883 | | *Robert B. Mackey (5) | | 1965 |
| *Herman N. Moore (5) | | 1884 | | *Edgar H. Clark (33) | | 1966 |
| *R. Allen Hall (10) | | 1885 | | *Frederick G. Kirby (55) | | 1967 |
| *William S. Lawrence (8) | | 1886 | | *Stanley H. Raidle (37) | | 1968 |
| *Thomas H. Williams (9) | | 1887 | | *Benjamin W. Wise (8) | | 1969 |
| *Charles P. Bigelow (23) | | 1888 | | *Rex R. Brubaker (1) | | 1970 |
| *John A. Gerow (17) | | 1889 | | Donald M. Krueger (18) | | 1971 |
| *William G. Doty (13) | | 1890 | | *Maurice L. Johnson (15) | | 1972 |
| *Edward C. Smith (2) | | 1891 | | *Max L. Clark (9) | | 1973 |
| *Jefferson S. Conover (10) | | 1892 | | *Carlton H. Cameron (17) | | 1974 |
| *Henry L. Anthony (18) | | 1893 | | *William R. Parker (28) | | 1975 |
| *Charles H. Pomeroy (26) | | 1894 | | *Richard M. Strauss (42) | | 1976 |
| *William E. Jewett (4) | | 1895 | | *C. Baird Penzien (26) | | 1977 |
| *Edward D. Wheeler (32) | | 1896 | | *Arthur B. Trevithick (13) | | 1978 |
| *Albert Stiles (9) | | 1897 | | *W. Jack Dover (15) | | 1979 |
| *Francis M. Moore (30) | | 1898 | | *P. Frederick Lesley (33) | | 1980 |
| *Eugene P. Robertson (17) | | 1899 | | Gilbert A. Rice (1) | | 1981 |
| *Phillip T. Van Zile (42) | | 1900 | | *Harold A. Price (25) | | 1982 |
| *Charles R. Hawley (26) | | 1901 | | Erwin W. O'Dell (17) | | 1982 |
| *James Findlater (1) | | 1902 | | *Arthur R. Ribble (16) | | 1983 |
| *Thomas E. Borden (16) | | 1903 | | *John F. Adams (7) | | 1984 |
| *Richard D. Swartout (5) | | 1904 | | *Donald G. McDonald (21) | | 1985 |
| *Frank C. Holmes (34) | | 1905 | | *Richard Webb, Jr. (42) | | 1986 |
| *Joseph H. Crawford (16) | | 1906 | | *Walter L. Skinner (15) | | 1987 |
| *Charles A. Warren (1) | | 1907 | | *John R. Howell (28) | | 1988 |
| *Hutson B. Coleman (8) | | 1908 | | *Archie MacDonald (53) | | 1989 |
| *Howard T. Taylor (4) | | 1909 | | Claude A. Miller (51) | | 1990 |
| *Charles G. Graham (40) | | 1910 | | Russell P. Livermore (1) | | 1991 |
| *William H. Kessler (1) | | 1911 | | *Richard N. Miller (39) | | 1992 |
| *George T. Campbell (21) | | 1912 | | *William R. Bannister (15) | | 1993 |
| *Charles E. Hiscock (13) | | 1913 | | Tommy R. Amidon (9) | | 1994 |
| *Gordon R. Campbell (38) | | 1914 | | *Thomas D. Coss (33) | | 1995 |
| *George L. Harvey (7) | | 1915 | | Richard E. Cooper (40) | | 1996 |
| *Fred A. Aldrich (15) | | 1916 | | Stanley O. Simons (25) | | 1997 |
| *Mark Norris (5) | | 1917 | | Richard D. Erspamer (15) | | 1998 |
| *Charles H. Patterson (9) | | 1918 | | *Robert C. Ickes (51) | | 1999 |
| *Edmond S. Rankin (8) | | 1919 | | James C. Costello (28) | | 2000 |
| *R. Guy Brownson (25) | | 1920 | | Richard E. Hansen (33) | | 2001 |
| *Lyle G. Younglove (1) | | 1921 | | *Ray M. Gibson (8) | | 2002 |
| *William E. Wetherbee (42) | | 1922 | | James E. Hawn (39) | | 2003 |
| *James E. Dividson (26) | | 1923 | | William Skrepnek (15) | | 2004 |
| *H. Bruce Moore (5) | | 1924 | | Vernon T. Barnhart (25) | | 2005 |
| *Albert L. Smith (28) | | 1925 | | Emmett W. Mills, Jr. (1) | | 2006 |
| *William E. Davidson (45) | | 1926 | | Glenn V. Leeper, Jr. (33) | | 2007 |
| *Charles G. Mahana (29)) | | 1927 | | David L. Seyferth (22) | | 2008 |
| *Charles E. Boyce (7) | | 1928 | | William P. Herlihy (7) | | 2009 |
| *Seth H. Jones (25) | | 1929 | | Loren A. Winn (28) | | 2010 |
| *John T. Fowler (2) | | 1930 | | | | |
| *Thane Benedict (11) | | 1931 | | | | |
| *Charles A.H. Thom (1) | | 1932 | | | | |
| *Clyde A. Fulton (37) | | 1933 | | | | |
| *Floyd A. Roberts (15) | | 1934 | | | | |
| *John H. Rademaker (32) | | 1935 | | | | |
| *Harry D. Brackett (47) | | 1936 | | | | |
| *Fred H. Locke (5) | | 1937 | | | | |
| *Elliott C. Davidson (44) | | 1938 | | | | |
| *Robert L. Robinson (18) | | 1939 | | | | |
| *James H. Garlick (42) | | 1940 | | | | |
