PAST GENERALISSIMOS FROM 1816
| Conclave | YEAR | NAME | CITY/STATE | Conclave | YEAR | NAME | CITY/STATE |
| I | 1816 | Henry Fowle | Boston, MA | XXXVII | 1928 | Harry Clay Walker | Binghamton, NY |
| II | 1819 | John Snow | Worthington, OH | XXXVIII | 1931 | Andrew Davison Agnew | Dec. 20, 1951 |
| III | 1826 | John James Loring | Boston, MA | XXXIX | 1934 | Harry Gilmore Pollard | Lowell, MA |
| IV | 1829 | Josiah Whitaker | Providence, RI | XL | 1937 | Charles Noah Orr | St. Paul, MN |
| V | 1832 | James Eyland | Charleston, SC | XLI | 1940 | John Temple Rice | El Paso, TX |
| VI | 1835 | James Herring | New York, NY | XLII | 1943 | Robert Brainerd Gaylord | San Francisco, CA |
| VII | 1838 | James Herring | New York, NY | XLIII | 1946 | Caleb Byron Lear | Ridgewood, NJ |
| VIII | 1841 | William James Reese | Lancaster, OH | XLIV | 1949 | Walter Stover | Watertown, SD |
| IX | 1844 | William Henry Ellis | New Haven, CT | | | Walter Allen DeLamater | Rhinebeck, NY |
| X | 1847 | William Henry Ellis | New Haven, CT | XLV | 1952 | Louis Henry Wieber | Cleveland, OH |
| XI | 1850 | Charles Whitlock Moore | Boston, MA | XLVI | 1955 | Paul Miller Moore | Aliquippa, PA |
| XII | 1853 | Charles Whitlock Moore | Boston, MA | XLVII | 1958 | Wilber Marion Brucker | Detroit, MI |
| XIII | 1856 | David Short Goodloe | Lexington, KY | XLVIII | 1961 | John Lawton Crofts, Sr. | Red Oak, IA |
| XIV | 1859 | Winslow Lewis | Boston, MA | XLIX | 1964 | George Wilbur Bell | Chandlerville, IL |
| XV | 1862 | Zenas Colville Priest | Utica, NY | L | 1967 | Roy Wilford Riegle | Emporia, KS |
| XVI | 1865 | John Quincy Adams Fellows | New Orleans, LA | LI | 1970 | William Meredith Avery | Knightstown, IN |
| XVII | 1868 | Kent Jarvis | Massillon, OH | LII | 1973 | John B. Cottrell, Jr. | Media, PA |
| XVIII | 1871 | Vincent Lombard Hurlbut | Chicago, IL | LIII | 1976 | Kenneth Culver Johnson | Little Rock, AR |
| XIX | 1874 | Walter Lawrence Bragg | Montgomery, AL | | 1977 | Ned Eugene Dull | Van Wert, OH |
| XX | 1877 | Benjamin Dean | Boston, MA | LIV | 1979 | William Porter Wilson | Woodland, CA |
| XXI | 1880 | Charles Roome | New York, NY | | | Donald Hinslea Smith | Richmond, KY |
| XXII | 1883 | John Peter Shindel Gobin | Lebanon, PA | LV | 1982 | Marvin Edward Fowler | Alexandria, VA |
| XXIII | 1886 | Hugh McCurdy | Corunna, MI | LVI | 1985 | William Henry Thornley, Jr. | Denver, CO |
| XXIV | 1889 | Warren LaRue Thomas | Danville, KY | LVII | 1988 | Blair Christy Mayford | St. Peters, MO |
| XXV | 1892 | Reuben Hedley Lloyd | San Francisco, CA | LVIII | 1991 | James Morris Ward | Jackson, MS |
| XXVI | 1895 | Henry Bates Stoddard | Bryan, TX | LIX | 1994 | William Jackson Jones | Villa Grove, IL |
| XXVII | 1898 | George Mayhew Moulton | Chicago, IL | LX | 1997 | Kenneth Bernard Fischer | Friendswood, TX |
| XXVIII | 1901 | Henry Warren Rugg | Providence, RI | LXI | 2000 | Richard Burditt Baldwin | Burke, VA |
| XXIX | 1904 | William Bromwell Melish | Cincinnati, OH | LXII | 2003 | William Howard Koon II | Columbus Grove, OH |
| XXX | 1907 | Arthur MacArthur | Troy, NY | LXIII | 2006 | David Dixon Goodwin | Vestal, NY |
| XXXI | 1910 | William Frank Pierce | San Francisco, CA | | 2007 | Sid Cornelius Dorris, III | Mount Juliet, TN |
| XXXII | 1913 | Joseph Kyle Orr | Atlanta, GA | LXIV | 2009 | Sid Cornelius Dorris, III | Mount Juliet, TN |
| XXXIII | 1916 | Jehiel Weston Chamberlin | St. Paul, MN | LXIV | 2010 | Duane Lee Vaught | Bloomington, IN |
| XXXIV | 1919 | Leonidas Perry Newby | Knightstown, IN | LXV | 2012 | Jeffrey Norman Nelson | Bismarck, ND |
| XXXV | 1922 | George William Vallery | Denver, CO | LXVI | 2015 | Michael Burke Johnson | Crowheart, WY |
| XXXVI | 1925 | Perry Winslow Weidner | Los Angeles, CA | LXVII | 2018 | David Joseph Kussman | Anaheim, CA |
|
